Pinchers Crab Shack, known for its crab dishes, fried fish & other shore favorites, has been operating in Southwest Florida for nearly 20 years. Pinchers and Island Crab utilize their own traps and boats to supply the restaurant with the freshest seafood available. It is a key element to what differentiates Pinchers from all the rest… No one can copy us because they can't. That's why our motto is… “You Can't Fake Fresh!”